The Science of High Intensity Interval Training-table
Study | Subjects | Study length | Protocol | Outcome | Best Result | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Helgerud-2007[1] |
Moderately trained (V̇O2max 51-55) |
3 days/week 8 weeks |
Short HIIT | Raised V̇O2max 5.5% |
Short and Long HIIT (no statistical difference) |
All groups improved economy, with no differences, and Lactate Threshold unchanged as a percentage of V̇O2max |
Long HIIT
4x 4 min, 90-95% HRmax + 3 min at 70%max |
Raised V̇O2max 7.2% | |||||
Lactate Threshold run
24 min at 85% HRmax |
V̇O2max unchanged | |||||
Long Slow Distance
45 minutes at 70% HRmax |
V̇O2max unchanged | |||||
TjonnaLee-2008[2] |
Untrained, metabolic syndrome patients |
3 days/week 16 weeks |
HIIT | Raised V̇O2max 36% |
HIIT |
Same calories burned in each group Both groups had an equal reduction in body weight and blood pressure |
Continuous Moderate Exercise
47 min at 70% HRmax |
Raised V̇O2max 16% | |||||
Gibala-2006[3] |
Recreationally active |
2 weeks |
HIIT
4-6x 30 seconds 'all out' + 4 min recovery Totals for two weeks, 135 minutes and 950 Kj |
Same improvement in laboratory time trials |
HIIT |
Same improvement, but only 22% of the time commitment |
Continuous Moderate Exercise
90-120 min at 65% V̇O2peak Totals for two weeks, 630 minutes and 6500 Kj | ||||||
Gorostiaga-1991[4] |
Sedentary |
3 days/week 8 weeks |
HIIT
30x 30 sec @ 100% V̇O2max + 30 sec rest |
Raised V̇O2max 9-16%
No change in blood Lactate during continuous exercise |
HIIT |
Same average work in each group |
Continuous Moderate Exercise
30 minutes at 50% V̇O2max |
Raised V̇O2max 5-7%
Reduced blood Lactate during continuous exercise by nearly 50% | |||||
Franch-1998[5] |
36 recreational runners |
3 days/week at high intensity Plus 3 runs/week <= 65% HRmax 6 weeks |
Short HIIT
30-40x 15 sec run, 15 sec rest Avg ~3.0 Km/workout 92% HRmax |
Time to exhaustion increased 65%
Running Economy improved 0.9% |
Continuous High Intensity |
Better improvements from continuous training than HIIT, but the continuous training is at an unusually high intensity that is probably close to a 10K race, three times a week. |
Long HIIT
4-6x 4 min run, 2 min rest Avg ~5.6 Km/workout 94% HRmax |
Time to exhaustion increased 67%
Running Economy improved 3.0% | |||||
Continuous High Intensity
20-30 minutes Avg ~6.4 Km/workout 93% HRmax |
Time to exhaustion increased 94%
Running Economy improved 3.1% | |||||
BurgomasterHowarth-2007[6] |
20 Untrained |
HIIT 3x week Continuous 5x week 6 weeks |
HIIT
4-6x 30 seconds 'all out', 4.5 min rest 1.5 hours/week ~225 Kj/week |
Both increased V̇O2peak by ~5% |
HIIT |
Similar changes in HIIT for 10% of the workload and 30% of the time of continuous training. |
Continuous Moderate Exercise
40-60 min at 65% V̇O2peak 4.5 hours/week 2250 Kj/week | ||||||
Trapp-2008[7] |
34 sedentary women |
45 workouts over 15 weeks |
HIIT
60x 8 seconds 'all out', 12 seconds rest (5 min Warmup, 20 min conditioning, 5 min Cooldown) |
Increased V̇O2peak 24%
5 pound/2.5 Kg reduction in body fat Significant 31% reduction in fasting insulin Significant reduction in Leptin |
HIIT |
HIIT produced similar improvements in fitness for a lower time commitment, as well as a reduction in body fat that was not seen with continuous exercise. |
Continuous Moderate Exercise
40 minutes at 60% V̇O2peak |
Increased V̇O2peak 19%
1 pound/0.5 Kg gain in body fat Non-significant 9% reduction in fasting insulin No change in Leptin | |||||
Tabata-1996[8] |
14 varsity level collage athletes (V̇O2max ~50) |
5 days/week 6 weeks |
HIIT
4 days/week 7-8x (30 seconds at 170% V̇O2max + 10 seconds rest) 1 day/week 30 min at 70% V̇O2max + 4x (30 seconds at 170% V̇O2max + 10 seconds rest) |
Raised V̇O2max by 14.5%
Increased anaerobic capacity by 28% |
HIIT |
HIIT produced a greater improvement in V̇O2max for far less time commitment |
Continuous Moderate Exercise
60 minutes at 70% V̇O2max |
Raised V̇O2max by 9.5%
No change in anaerobic capacity | |||||
EarnestTjønna-2013[9] |
26 healthy overweight men (BMI 25-30) |
3 days/week 10 weeks |
4x HIIT
10 min Warmup 4x 4 min at 90% HRmax + 3 min 70% HRmax 5 min Cooldown total 40 min |
Raised V̇O2max by 13%
Work economy improved by 13% Systolic blood pressure decreased 3.2 mmHg Diastolic blood pressure decreased 6.3 mmHg |
Similar results with both protocols |
This study showed remarkable results using a single high intensity bout of exercise. |
1x HIIT
10 min Warmup 4 min at 90% HRmax 5 min Cooldown total 19 min |
Raised V̇O2max by 10%
Work economy improved by 14% Systolic blood pressure decreased 6.2 mmHg Diastolic blood pressure decreased 7.7 mmHg |
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedHelgerud-2007
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedTjonnaLee2008
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedGibala-2006
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedGorostiaga-1991
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedFranch-1998
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedBurgomasterHowarth2007
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedTrapp-2008
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedTabata-1996
- ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>
tag; no text was provided for refs namedEarnestTj.C3.B8nna2013
- Category:Pages with reference errors