8,153
edits
Changes
From Fellrnr.com, Running tips
no edit summary
{{DISPLAYTITLE:Tempo Runs, the least effective form of training}}
A tempo run, sometimes called a threshold run, is a common part of many training programs as coaches believe it is an effective way of improving lactate clearance. However, the science indicates that tempo paced runs should be avoided in favor of other paces. Tempo pace represents the no man's land between [[Long Run| Long Slow Distance]] and [[High Intensity Interval Training]]. They are too fast to be long, and too slow to be intense. They can improve performance in the untrained, but not as well as other types of training and so they are the least effective form of training. In fact, for highly trained runners there is evidence that Tempo Runs may actually be counterproductive. While there are claims that Tempo Runs have benefits for [[Mental fortitude]] this is not supported by the science that has looked at race performance. Note that performing intervals at Tempo, Threshold, or other sub-maximum effort can be considered [[Medium Intensity High Volume Intervals]] rather than a tempo run, which is typically continuous.
=What is a Tempo Run?=
A Tempo Run intended to be run at or near the pace corresponding to the [[Lactate Threshold]]<ref name="Lifehacker2016"/><ref name="RunnersWorldWhatIs"/>. Lactate Threshold can be thought of as the transition from mostly aerobic to mostly anaerobic metabolism. In well trained athletes, paces below the Lactate Threshold can be kept up for prolonged periods (several hours), where paces about the Lactate Threshold typically cannot be maintained for more than an hour. The specific definitions vary a little, as it's tough to measure Lactate Threshold, more properly called "Maximum Lactate Steady State" or MLSS (See [[Lactate Threshold]] for more details.) Some example definitions:* Jack Daniels defines Threshold Pace as 83-88% of [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>max]], or 88-92% of your pace at [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>max]], or 88-92% of [[Maximum Heart Rate]], which he intends to be MLSS pace<ref name="JackDaniels2015"/>.* The [[FIRST]] training plans use a pace slightly slower than 10K pace or marathon pace.* The [[Hanson| Hanson's Marathon Method]] uses marathon pace for tempo runs.
=The Tempo Myth=
There is a prevalent myth that Tempo runs are an important part of a training program. The idea is that running at Lactate Threshold pace improves Lactate clearance and thus improves performance.
The idea that training at threshold intensity is particularly effective has no evidence<ref name="Beneke-2011"/>. However, this is not the same as saying that tempo runs are not effective at all, just that they are not more effective than other forms of training.
==Evidence in Favor of Tempo Runs==
* Tempo runs can improve performance in untrained subjects<ref name="Denis-1982"/><ref name="Denis-1984"/><ref name="Londeree-1997"/>. However , these studies did not compare how effective tempo runs are over other forms of training. * A study of 9 experienced recreational masters runners showed a dramatic improvement (50%) in time to exhaustion at Lactate Threshold after interval training at Lactate Threshold pace<ref name="Billat-2004"/>. The runners had an average half marathon time of 83 minutes (+/-5), but had never performed any form of speedwork. Their average training before the study was five runs per week for an average of 65 minutes at 12.4 KPH (7:36 min/mile). The study lasted for 6 weeks, with 2 tempo paced interval sessions replacing 2 of the slower paced runs per week. One session was 3 intervals of 10 minutes each, the second 2 intervals of 15 minutes. Each week the shorter and longer intervals were lengthened by 2 and 3 minutes respectively. After training [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>max]] increased 3.6% and Velocity at Lactate Threshold increased 4.2% (13.8 to 15.2 KPH, or 7:00 to 6:21). More impressively, the time to exhaustion at Lactate Threshold pace increased by a massive 50% from an average of 44 minutes before to 63 minutes after training. Unfortunately , the study did not include any form of controls to know how much familiarity with the testing procedure influenced the results, nor was there any comparison with other forms of training such as [[High Intensity Interval Training]].
* Four weeks of tempo training increased [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>max]] by 10% in moderately trained runners<ref name="PhilpMacdonald2008"/>. The only control was performing interval training just above or just below tempo pace, which resulted in a smaller (6%) improvement.
==Evidence Against Tempo Runs==
* Moderately trained subjects trained for 3 days/week for 8 weeks using either Short HIIT, Long HIIT, Tempo runs, or LSD<ref name="Helgerud-2007"/>. [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>max]] was unchanged in the tempo and LSD groups, but increased 7.2% in the Short HIIT and 5.5% in the Long HIIT groups.
* Training at lower intensity (blood lactate < 2 mmol/l) is more effective at improving performance at the Lactate Threshold than training at the Lactate Threshold (3-6 mmol/l)<ref name="Guellich-2010"/>.
* A 2007 randomly assigned 12 sub-elite 5K & cross -country runners to one of two training programs<ref name="Esteve-Lanao-2007"/>. The Z1 program had 80% LSD, 10% Tempo, and 10% HIIT, whereas the Z2 program had 65% LSD, 25% Tempo, and 10% HIIT. The Z1 group that did less time at Tempo pace improved their race performance more than the Z2 group. (Their simulated 10K times improved 35 seconds more, 157 second improvement rather than 121 second improvement.)
* A 2009 review of the science of training intensity noted that recreational runners typically fall into a "black hole" of too much Lactate Threshold running<ref name="Seiler-2009"/>. They noted "''Training intended to be longer and slower becomes too fast and shorter in duration, and interval training fails to reach the desired intensity. The result is that most training sessions end up being performed at the same threshold intensity''."
* The performance of elite 5k/10K runners is related to total time spent in low intensity training, not higher intensities<ref name="Esteve-Lanao-2005"/>.
=Why Are Tempo Runs Ineffective?=
The improvements in Lactate Threshold pace are largely due to a greater rate of Lactate removal rather than reduced rate of production<ref name="Phillips-1995"/><ref name="MacRae-1992"/><ref name="Donovan-1989"/><ref name="Donovan-1983"/><ref name="Bergman-1999"/>. All muscle fibers release lactate at rest, but switch to net absorption as lactate levels rise<ref name="Donovan-2000"/>. There is some evidence that slow twitch (endurance) muscle fibers become net consumers of Lactate at lower concentrations, and absorb more Lactate at any given concentration than fast twitch fibers<ref name="Donovan-2000"/>. In addition, slow twitch fibers are better suited for Lactate oxidation than fast twitch<ref name="Gladden2000"/>, as well as having better Lactate Transport (in and out of the muscle)<ref name="Juel-1997"/>. It seems reasonable that low intensity exercise focuses more on slow twitch fibers, and is therefore more effective at improving Lactate Threshold than higher intensities. However, I have not located any research to support that hypothesis.
=The Norwegian Method=
''Main article: [[Medium Intensity High Volume Intervals]]''
The success of athletes such as the Ingebrigtsen brothers, Kristian Blummenfelt, and others has created interest in the "Norwegian method". Originally, the Norwegian method seemed to mean 4x4 minute intervals at 90-95% max HR<ref name="JanHoff"/>, but the meaning has changed since then. As of July 2023, the Norwegian method is based on training anecdotes of elite Norwegian athletes, with no defined formal protocol and no testing of the approach in other athletes. This makes it extremely difficult to understand, as the information is so incomplete, but a review of what's available gives some sense of the approach. These athletes use both heart rate and lactate measurements as part of their training, using lactate to guide their intensity. The value of using lactate over heart rate is unclear to me and is impractical for most athletes due to the cost. However, the key to the Norwegian method is that they seem to focus on [[Medium Intensity High Volume Intervals]] rather than Tempo runs. While the intensity is similar, the Norwegian method uses lower intensity than Tempo/Threshold pace combined with a high volume of intervals<ref name="Pajulahti2020"/><ref name="mariusbakken2022"/><ref name="Casado2023"/><ref name="Tjelta2019"/>.
=References=
<references>
<ref name="mariusbakken2022">http://www.mariusbakken.com/the-norwegian-model.html, The Norwegian model of lactate threshold training and lactate controlled approach to training, July 31, 2023 !!access-date!!</ref>
<ref name="Pajulahti2020">https://pajulahti.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Jan-Bengtsson-Pajulahti.pdf, Training philosophy to 1500m Swedish record 3.33,70, July 31, 2023 !!access-date!!</ref>
<ref name="Casado2023">2023, Does Lactate-Guided Threshold Interval Training within a High-Volume Low-Intensity Approach Represent the "Next Step" in the Evolution of Distance Running Training?, publisher MDPI AG, http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20053782</ref>
<ref name="Tjelta2019">2019, Three Norwegian brothers all European 1500 m champions: What is the secret?, publisher SAGE Publications, http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1747954119872321</ref>
<ref name="JanHoff">https://youtu.be/qUSy0P7UHW8, The Norwegian method, Jan Hoff, publisher TEDx, date Dec 9, 2016, Youtube !!website!!, July 31, 2023 !!access-date!!</ref>
<ref name="Juel-1997">C. Juel, Lactate-proton cotransport in skeletal muscle., Physiol Rev, volume 77, issue 2, pages 321-58, Apr 1997, PMID [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9114817 9114817]</ref>
<ref name="Gladden2000">L. Bruce Gladden, Muscle as a consumer of lactate, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, volume 32, issue 4, 2000, pages 764–771, ISSN [http://www.worldcat.org/issn/0195-9131 0195-9131], doi [http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00005768-200004000-00008 10.1097/00005768-200004000-00008]</ref>
<ref name="PhilpMacdonald2008">A. Philp, A. Macdonald, H. Carter, P. Watt, J. Pringle, Maximal Lactate Steady State as a Training Stimulus, International Journal of Sports Medicine, volume 29, issue 6, 2008, pages 475–479, ISSN [http://www.worldcat.org/issn/0172-4622 0172-4622], doi [http://dx.doi.org/10.1055/s-2007-965320 10.1055/s-2007-965320]</ref>
<ref name="Donovan-2000">CM. Donovan, MJ. Pagliassotti, Quantitative assessment of pathways for lactate disposal in skeletal muscle fiber types., Med Sci Sports Exerc, volume 32, issue 4, pages 772-7, Apr 2000, PMID [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10776896 10776896]</ref>
<ref name="Lifehacker2016">http://lifehacker.com/a-step-by-step-guide-to-tempo-runs-1781580399</ref>
<ref name="RunnersWorldWhatIs">http://www.runnersworld.com/workouts/what-is-a-tempo-run</ref>
</references>