Difference between revisions of "GPS Accuracy-statistics"
From Fellrnr.com, Running tips
User:Fellrnr (User talk:Fellrnr | contribs) |
User:Fellrnr (User talk:Fellrnr | contribs) |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
− | {| class="wikitable" | + | {| class="wikitable sortable" |
!rowspan="2"|Device | !rowspan="2"|Device | ||
!rowspan="2"|Count | !rowspan="2"|Count | ||
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
!rowspan="2"|Standard Deviation<br/>(From mean) | !rowspan="2"|Standard Deviation<br/>(From mean) | ||
!rowspan="2"|Standard Deviation<br/>(From true) | !rowspan="2"|Standard Deviation<br/>(From true) | ||
− | !colspan="2"| | + | !colspan="2"|Pace Error (95%) |
+ | !colspan="2"|Distance Error | ||
|- | |- | ||
!(from 9:00 min/mile) | !(from 9:00 min/mile) | ||
!(from 5:30 min/Km) | !(from 5:30 min/Km) | ||
+ | !(20 miles) | ||
+ | !(30 Km) | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Footpod (calibrated) | |Footpod (calibrated) | ||
Line 15: | Line 18: | ||
|style="background-color: #63BE7B;"|2.34% (123.4 Ft/Mile, 23.4 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #63BE7B;"|2.34% (123.4 Ft/Mile, 23.4 m/Km) | ||
|style="background-color: #63BE7B;"|2.34% (123.6 Ft/Mile, 23.4 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #63BE7B;"|2.34% (123.6 Ft/Mile, 23.4 m/Km) | ||
− | |0: | + | |0:25 |
− | |0: | + | |0:15 |
+ | |0.03 | ||
+ | |0.04 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Polar V800}} | |{{Polar V800}} | ||
|1095 | |1095 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #68BF7B;"|0.22% (11.5 Ft/Mile, 2.2 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #68BF7B;"|2.41% (127.1 Ft/Mile, 24.1 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #68BF7B;"|2.41% (127.1 Ft/Mile, 24.1 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #67BF7B;"|2.42% (127.6 Ft/Mile, 24.2 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:26 |
− | |0: | + | |0:16 |
+ | |0.04 | ||
+ | |0.07 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 205}} | |{{Garmin 205}} | ||
|1125 | |1125 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #79C47C;"|0.47% (24.9 Ft/Mile, 4.7 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #A4D07E;"|3.14% (166.0 Ft/Mile, 31.4 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #A4D07E;"|3.14% (166.0 Ft/Mile, 31.4 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #98CD7E;"|3.18% (167.9 Ft/Mile, 31.8 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:34 |
− | |0: | + | |0:21 |
+ | |0.09 | ||
+ | |0.14 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 910XT}} with [[Footpod]] | |{{Garmin 910XT}} with [[Footpod]] | ||
|725 | |725 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #AED37F;"|1.28% (67.8 Ft/Mile, 12.8 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #94CC7D;"|2.94% (155.4 Ft/Mile, 29.4 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #94CC7D;"|2.94% (155.4 Ft/Mile, 29.4 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #9BCE7E;"|3.21% (169.6 Ft/Mile, 32.1 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:35 |
− | |0: | + | |0:21 |
+ | |0.26 | ||
+ | |0.39 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|iPhone 4s | |iPhone 4s | ||
|956 | |956 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #94CC7D;"|0.90% (47.3 Ft/Mile, 9.0 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #A3D07E;"|3.12% (164.9 Ft/Mile, 31.2 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #A3D07E;"|3.12% (164.9 Ft/Mile, 31.2 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #9DCE7E;"|3.25% (171.6 Ft/Mile, 32.5 m/Km) |
− | |0:18 | + | |0:35 |
− | |0 | + | |0:21 |
+ | |0.18 | ||
+ | |0.27 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 310XT}} with [[Footpod]] | |{{Garmin 310XT}} with [[Footpod]] | ||
|3724 | |3724 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #83C77C;"|0.62% (33.0 Ft/Mile, 6.2 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #B1D47F;"|3.30% (174.1 Ft/Mile, 33.0 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #B1D47F;"|3.30% (174.1 Ft/Mile, 33.0 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #A4D07E;"|3.36% (177.2 Ft/Mile, 33.6 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:36 |
− | |0: | + | |0:22 |
+ | |0.12 | ||
+ | |0.19 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 610}} | |{{Garmin 610}} | ||
|2085 | |2085 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #CDDC81;"|1.77% (93.3 Ft/Mile, 17.7 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #A4D07E;"|3.14% (165.9 Ft/Mile, 31.4 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #A4D07E;"|3.14% (165.9 Ft/Mile, 31.4 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #B4D57F;"|3.61% (190.3 Ft/Mile, 36.1 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:39 |
− | |0: | + | |0:24 |
+ | |0.35 | ||
+ | |0.53 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 620}} (3.30) | |{{Garmin 620}} (3.30) | ||
|1130 | |1130 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #CDDC81;"|1.76% (92.9 Ft/Mile, 17.6 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #AFD47F;"|3.28% (173.1 Ft/Mile, 32.8 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #AFD47F;"|3.28% (173.1 Ft/Mile, 32.8 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #BBD780;"|3.72% (196.5 Ft/Mile, 37.2 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:40 |
− | |0: | + | |0:25 |
+ | |0.35 | ||
+ | |0.53 | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |{{Garmin 920XT}} | ||
+ | |755 | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #FCEA83;"|2.48% (131.2 Ft/Mile, 24.8 m/Km) | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #A1D07E;"|3.11% (164.0 Ft/Mile, 31.1 m/Km) | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #CCDC81;"|3.98% (210.1 Ft/Mile, 39.8 m/Km) | ||
+ | |0:43 | ||
+ | |0:26 | ||
+ | |0.50 | ||
+ | |0.75 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 310XT}} no [[Footpod]] | |{{Garmin 310XT}} no [[Footpod]] | ||
|1945 | |1945 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #97CD7E;"|0.94% (49.8 Ft/Mile, 9.4 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #E5E382;"|3.94% (208.0 Ft/Mile, 39.4 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #E5E382;"|3.94% (208.0 Ft/Mile, 39.4 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #D1DD81;"|4.05% (213.9 Ft/Mile, 40.5 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:44 |
− | |0: | + | |0:27 |
+ | |0.19 | ||
+ | |0.28 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Samsung Galaxy S3 | |Samsung Galaxy S3 | ||
|832 | |832 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #AED37F;"|1.28% (67.7 Ft/Mile, 12.8 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #EAE582;"|4.00% (211.4 Ft/Mile, 40.0 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #EAE582;"|4.00% (211.4 Ft/Mile, 40.0 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #DBE081;"|4.20% (222.0 Ft/Mile, 42.0 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:45 |
− | |0: | + | |0:28 |
+ | |0.26 | ||
+ | |0.38 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Suunto Ambit2 R}} | |{{Suunto Ambit2 R}} | ||
|1025 | |1025 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #A5D17E;"|1.15% (60.9 Ft/Mile, 11.5 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #F1E783;"|4.08% (215.7 Ft/Mile, 40.8 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #F1E783;"|4.08% (215.7 Ft/Mile, 40.8 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #DDE182;"|4.24% (224.1 Ft/Mile, 42.4 m/Km) |
− | |0:23 | + | |0:46 |
− | |0 | + | |0:28 |
+ | |0.23 | ||
+ | |0.35 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Footpod (uncalibrated) | |Footpod (uncalibrated) | ||
|3724 | |3724 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FAE983;"|2.46% (129.8 Ft/Mile, 24.6 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #DAE081;"|3.81% (201.0 Ft/Mile, 38.1 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #DAE081;"|3.81% (201.0 Ft/Mile, 38.1 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #F0E683;"|4.53% (239.3 Ft/Mile, 45.3 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:49 |
− | |0: | + | |0:30 |
+ | |0.49 | ||
+ | |0.74 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Polar RC3 GPS}} | |{{Polar RC3 GPS}} | ||
|1433 | |1433 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #C5DA80;"|1.65% (86.9 Ft/Mile, 16.5 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #FED280;"|4.62% (244.2 Ft/Mile, 46.2 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #FED280;"|4.62% (244.2 Ft/Mile, 46.2 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FFE483;"|4.91% (259.2 Ft/Mile, 49.1 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:53 |
− | |0: | + | |0:32 |
+ | |0.33 | ||
+ | |0.49 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{TomTom Cardio Runner}} | |{{TomTom Cardio Runner}} | ||
|946 | |946 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FDBB7B;"|3.42% (180.6 Ft/Mile, 34.2 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #CEDC81;"|3.65% (192.8 Ft/Mile, 36.5 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #CEDC81;"|3.65% (192.8 Ft/Mile, 36.5 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FFDE82;"|5.00% (264.2 Ft/Mile, 50.0 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:54 |
− | |0: | + | |0:33 |
+ | |0.68 | ||
+ | |1.03 | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |{{Garmin 920XT}} (GLONASS) | ||
+ | |712 | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #FDBD7C;"|3.37% (178.0 Ft/Mile, 33.7 m/Km) | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #D8DF81;"|3.78% (199.4 Ft/Mile, 37.8 m/Km) | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #FFDB81;"|5.06% (267.4 Ft/Mile, 50.6 m/Km) | ||
+ | |0:55 | ||
+ | |0:33 | ||
+ | |0.67 | ||
+ | |1.01 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Fenix 2}} (3.30) | |{{Fenix 2}} (3.30) | ||
|1111 | |1111 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FFE383;"|2.68% (141.4 Ft/Mile, 26.8 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #FED380;"|4.61% (243.3 Ft/Mile, 46.1 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #FED380;"|4.61% (243.3 Ft/Mile, 46.1 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FECD7F;"|5.33% (281.4 Ft/Mile, 53.3 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |0:58 |
− | |0: | + | |0:35 |
+ | |0.54 | ||
+ | |0.80 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 10}} | |{{Garmin 10}} | ||
|1042 | |1042 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FBA176;"|3.89% (205.4 Ft/Mile, 38.9 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #FFE383;"|4.37% (231.0 Ft/Mile, 43.7 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #FFE383;"|4.37% (231.0 Ft/Mile, 43.7 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FCB179;"|5.86% (309.2 Ft/Mile, 58.6 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |1:03 |
− | |0 | + | |0:39 |
+ | |0.78 | ||
+ | |1.17 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Garmin 620}} (pre-v3.30) | |{{Garmin 620}} (pre-v3.30) | ||
− | | | + | |3320 |
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FDC17C;"|3.31% (174.8 Ft/Mile, 33.1 m/Km) |
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FCA978;"|5.23% (276.1 Ft/Mile, 52.3 m/Km) |
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FB9F76;"|6.19% (326.8 Ft/Mile, 61.9 m/Km) |
− | | | + | |1:07 |
− | |0: | + | |0:41 |
− | + | |0.66 | |
− | + | |0.99 | |
− | |||
− | |||
− | | | ||
− | | | ||
− | |||
− | |||
|- | |- | ||
|{{Fenix 2}} (pre-v3.30) | |{{Fenix 2}} (pre-v3.30) | ||
|4378 | |4378 | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FFDD82;"|2.79% (147.4 Ft/Mile, 27.9 m/Km) |
|style="background-color: #F8696B;"|6.16% (325.3 Ft/Mile, 61.6 m/Km) | |style="background-color: #F8696B;"|6.16% (325.3 Ft/Mile, 61.6 m/Km) | ||
− | |style="background-color: # | + | |style="background-color: #FA8070;"|6.76% (357.2 Ft/Mile, 67.6 m/Km) |
− | |0: | + | |1:13 |
− | |0: | + | |0:45 |
+ | |0.56 | ||
+ | |0.84 | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |{{Polar M400}} | ||
+ | |1556 | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #F8696B;"|4.91% (259.2 Ft/Mile, 49.1 m/Km) | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #FCA878;"|5.24% (276.7 Ft/Mile, 52.4 m/Km) | ||
+ | |style="background-color: #F8696B;"|7.18% (379.2 Ft/Mile, 71.8 m/Km) | ||
+ | |1:18 | ||
+ | |0:47 | ||
+ | |0.98 | ||
+ | |1.47 | ||
|} | |} |
Revision as of 15:47, 11 January 2015
Device | Count | Trueness (Average Distance Error) |
Standard Deviation (From mean) |
Standard Deviation (From true) |
Pace Error (95%) | Distance Error | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(from 9:00 min/mile) | (from 5:30 min/Km) | (20 miles) | (30 Km) | |||||
Footpod (calibrated) | 3724 | 0.13% (7.1 Ft/Mile, 1.3 m/Km) | 2.34% (123.4 Ft/Mile, 23.4 m/Km) | 2.34% (123.6 Ft/Mile, 23.4 m/Km) | 0:25 | 0:15 | 0.03 | 0.04 |
Polar V800 | 1095 | 0.22% (11.5 Ft/Mile, 2.2 m/Km) | 2.41% (127.1 Ft/Mile, 24.1 m/Km) | 2.42% (127.6 Ft/Mile, 24.2 m/Km) | 0:26 | 0:16 | 0.04 | 0.07 |
Garmin 205 | 1125 | 0.47% (24.9 Ft/Mile, 4.7 m/Km) | 3.14% (166.0 Ft/Mile, 31.4 m/Km) | 3.18% (167.9 Ft/Mile, 31.8 m/Km) | 0:34 | 0:21 | 0.09 | 0.14 |
Garmin 910XT with Footpod | 725 | 1.28% (67.8 Ft/Mile, 12.8 m/Km) | 2.94% (155.4 Ft/Mile, 29.4 m/Km) | 3.21% (169.6 Ft/Mile, 32.1 m/Km) | 0:35 | 0:21 | 0.26 | 0.39 |
iPhone 4s | 956 | 0.90% (47.3 Ft/Mile, 9.0 m/Km) | 3.12% (164.9 Ft/Mile, 31.2 m/Km) | 3.25% (171.6 Ft/Mile, 32.5 m/Km) | 0:35 | 0:21 | 0.18 | 0.27 |
Garmin 310XT with Footpod | 3724 | 0.62% (33.0 Ft/Mile, 6.2 m/Km) | 3.30% (174.1 Ft/Mile, 33.0 m/Km) | 3.36% (177.2 Ft/Mile, 33.6 m/Km) | 0:36 | 0:22 | 0.12 | 0.19 |
Garmin 610 | 2085 | 1.77% (93.3 Ft/Mile, 17.7 m/Km) | 3.14% (165.9 Ft/Mile, 31.4 m/Km) | 3.61% (190.3 Ft/Mile, 36.1 m/Km) | 0:39 | 0:24 | 0.35 | 0.53 |
Garmin 620 (3.30) | 1130 | 1.76% (92.9 Ft/Mile, 17.6 m/Km) | 3.28% (173.1 Ft/Mile, 32.8 m/Km) | 3.72% (196.5 Ft/Mile, 37.2 m/Km) | 0:40 | 0:25 | 0.35 | 0.53 |
Garmin 920XT | 755 | 2.48% (131.2 Ft/Mile, 24.8 m/Km) | 3.11% (164.0 Ft/Mile, 31.1 m/Km) | 3.98% (210.1 Ft/Mile, 39.8 m/Km) | 0:43 | 0:26 | 0.50 | 0.75 |
Garmin 310XT no Footpod | 1945 | 0.94% (49.8 Ft/Mile, 9.4 m/Km) | 3.94% (208.0 Ft/Mile, 39.4 m/Km) | 4.05% (213.9 Ft/Mile, 40.5 m/Km) | 0:44 | 0:27 | 0.19 | 0.28 |
Samsung Galaxy S3 | 832 | 1.28% (67.7 Ft/Mile, 12.8 m/Km) | 4.00% (211.4 Ft/Mile, 40.0 m/Km) | 4.20% (222.0 Ft/Mile, 42.0 m/Km) | 0:45 | 0:28 | 0.26 | 0.38 |
Suunto Ambit2 R | 1025 | 1.15% (60.9 Ft/Mile, 11.5 m/Km) | 4.08% (215.7 Ft/Mile, 40.8 m/Km) | 4.24% (224.1 Ft/Mile, 42.4 m/Km) | 0:46 | 0:28 | 0.23 | 0.35 |
Footpod (uncalibrated) | 3724 | 2.46% (129.8 Ft/Mile, 24.6 m/Km) | 3.81% (201.0 Ft/Mile, 38.1 m/Km) | 4.53% (239.3 Ft/Mile, 45.3 m/Km) | 0:49 | 0:30 | 0.49 | 0.74 |
Polar RC3 GPS | 1433 | 1.65% (86.9 Ft/Mile, 16.5 m/Km) | 4.62% (244.2 Ft/Mile, 46.2 m/Km) | 4.91% (259.2 Ft/Mile, 49.1 m/Km) | 0:53 | 0:32 | 0.33 | 0.49 |
TomTom Cardio Runner | 946 | 3.42% (180.6 Ft/Mile, 34.2 m/Km) | 3.65% (192.8 Ft/Mile, 36.5 m/Km) | 5.00% (264.2 Ft/Mile, 50.0 m/Km) | 0:54 | 0:33 | 0.68 | 1.03 |
Garmin 920XT (GLONASS) | 712 | 3.37% (178.0 Ft/Mile, 33.7 m/Km) | 3.78% (199.4 Ft/Mile, 37.8 m/Km) | 5.06% (267.4 Ft/Mile, 50.6 m/Km) | 0:55 | 0:33 | 0.67 | 1.01 |
Garmin Fenix 2 (3.30) | 1111 | 2.68% (141.4 Ft/Mile, 26.8 m/Km) | 4.61% (243.3 Ft/Mile, 46.1 m/Km) | 5.33% (281.4 Ft/Mile, 53.3 m/Km) | 0:58 | 0:35 | 0.54 | 0.80 |
Garmin 10 | 1042 | 3.89% (205.4 Ft/Mile, 38.9 m/Km) | 4.37% (231.0 Ft/Mile, 43.7 m/Km) | 5.86% (309.2 Ft/Mile, 58.6 m/Km) | 1:03 | 0:39 | 0.78 | 1.17 |
Garmin 620 (pre-v3.30) | 3320 | 3.31% (174.8 Ft/Mile, 33.1 m/Km) | 5.23% (276.1 Ft/Mile, 52.3 m/Km) | 6.19% (326.8 Ft/Mile, 61.9 m/Km) | 1:07 | 0:41 | 0.66 | 0.99 |
Garmin Fenix 2 (pre-v3.30) | 4378 | 2.79% (147.4 Ft/Mile, 27.9 m/Km) | 6.16% (325.3 Ft/Mile, 61.6 m/Km) | 6.76% (357.2 Ft/Mile, 67.6 m/Km) | 1:13 | 0:45 | 0.56 | 0.84 |
Polar M400 | 1556 | 4.91% (259.2 Ft/Mile, 49.1 m/Km) | 5.24% (276.7 Ft/Mile, 52.4 m/Km) | 7.18% (379.2 Ft/Mile, 71.8 m/Km) | 1:18 | 0:47 | 0.98 | 1.47 |