8,137
edits
Changes
From Fellrnr.com, Running tips
no edit summary
There is remarkably little scientific research available around exercise while on a [[Ketogenic Diet]]. The For a long time, the only useful research I found was a single study by Phinney in 1983. While this is a fascinating study, it has few subjects, it has not been confirmed with other studies and the results of the study are somewhat ambiguous. A 2016 study on race walkers has provided more insight, and I've covered both studies in some detail. I've also included some other studies that are on [[Non-Ketogenic Low Carbohydrate Diets]]. __NOTOC__=Burke's Study of Race Walkers=Unlike the Phinney study described below, the study by Burke<ref name="BurkeRoss2016"/> is not performed by proponents of a low carbohydrate or ketogenic diet. The study seems to have a reasonable approach, though it's not without its flaws. The main problem with this study is that it looks at a relatively small number of subjects, and the subjects are all elite athletes. This means that the findings may not translate to recreational athletes, or even sub-elite athletes. However, I'd argue this is probably the best study we have so far on the ketogenic diet for athletes. The high-level finding of the study is that athletes performed worse on a low carbohydrate, ketogenic diet. The fundamental problem that the study highlights with a low carbohydrate, ketogenic diet is that it requires more oxygen to produce a given amount of energy from fat than it does from carbohydrate. This problem is highlighted not just in the somewhat artificial, laboratory tests, but also in race performances.* The study subjects were 21 elite race walkers. Their event is the 20Km race walk, which takes an elite athlete 75-80 minutes and is completed at about 90% of [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>max]]<ref name="Drake-2003"/>. That means the subjects are focused on a moderate lengths endurance event, roughly similar to runners in a half marathon. The high intensity of this event means that the results might not translate to ultramarathons in the same way.* The study took place during a three-week intense training block, that included weight training, race walking, and endurance cross training using running, cycling, or swimming.* The subjects were divided into 3 different groups; one group was given a standard high carbohydrate diet (HCHO), another group was given a Low CHO, high fat (LCHF), and the third group cycled between high carb and low carb (Periodised CHO or PCHO). All 3 diets were matched for overall energy intake.** The High Carb (HCHO) group got 60-65% of their calories from carbohydrate, 15-20% protein, 20% fat. ** The Periodised CHO (PCHO) group had the same average nutrient balance as the high carb diet, but performed some of their training in a low carbohydrate or fasted state.** The Low CHO, high fat (LCHF) was 75-80% fat, 15-20% protein, and less than 50g of carbohydrate per day. The study doesn't give as many details on the ketone levels as I'd like, but they do measure BOHB (beta-hydroxybutyrate) and show levels well above 1.0 when measured at rest. This indicates the low carbohydrate athletes are clearly in ketosis during the testing phase. Given the overall protocol, I think it's reasonable to conclude that the athletes were keto adapted by the end of the study.* There were a number of tests performed, including [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>peak]], 25Km long walk, and simulated 10Km race. The simulated race even had prize money as incentive, so one could perhaps think of this as more of a true race than a race simulation. In fact, four of the subjects set personal best times in the simulated race, and one even said a national record.* The low carbohydrate athletes had problems during training, with higher rates of perceived exertion, and higher heart rates, and the inability to complete some of the training sessions. It's unclear if these problems were only at the beginning of the training, before they'd adapted to the low carbohydrate diet, or if they persisted through to the end.* LCHF had problems completing the training, complaining of higher perceived effort and inability to complete the training sessions. (Adaptation period?)* The oxygen cost of exercise was higher in the low carbohydrate group than a high carbohydrate group, while the periodised carbohydrate group had a slightly lower oxygen cost and the high carbohydrate group.* The subjects performed the simulated race before and after the dietary intervention. The race times were improved in the high carbohydrate group by an average of 190 seconds (114-266) and in the periodised carbohydrate group by 124s (62-186). However, the low carbohydrate group was slower by an average of 23 seconds (162-208, a range that makes no sense and I've queried with the authors). It looks like the low carbohydrate athletes increased their [[VO2max|V̇O<sub>2</sub>peak]] at the end of the study, but this increase was negated by the impaired economy of higher oxygen cost of exercise.* The low carbohydrate group burned more fat during the end of study tests by a rather dramatic amount.
=Phinney's Study of Elite Cyclists=
A classic study was performed in 1983 by Stephen Phinney on the effect of four weeks on a [[Ketogenic Diet]] on 5 elite cyclists, and found that on average their endurance was maintained<ref name="Phinney-1983"/>. However, this average represents two subjects that dramatically improved their endurance, one that didn't change and two subjects that had dramatically reduced endurance. One of the subjects that had reduced performance was [[Overtraining| Overtrained]], and if their results are excluded the average is a 13% improvement.
* Muscle [[Glycogen]] levels where higher before the endurance test on the normal diet than on the [[Ketogenic Diet]] (143 and 53 respectively). Both tests had similar muscle glycogen levels after the endurance tests. It is interesting to see that muscle glycogen levels were replenished somewhat on the [[Ketogenic Diet]], even though the subjects continued normal training for the four weeks.
{| class="wikitable"
!
! Endurace-1
! Endurance-2
|-
| Average
| |
| 4%
| |
| -63%
| 75.5
|
| -24%
| 10%
| -38%
| |
| 2%
|
|-
| Exclude WB
| |
| 13%
| |
| -65%
| 73.8
|
| -24%
| 12%
| -41%
| |
| -1%
|
=References=
<references>
<ref name="BurkeRoss2016">Louise M Burke, Megan L Ross, Laura A Garvican-Lewis, Marijke Welvaert, Ida A Heikura, Sara G Forbes, Joanne G Mirtschin, Louise E Cato, Nicki Strobel, Avish P Sharma, John A Hawley, Low Carbohydrate, High Fat diet impairs exercise economy and negates the performance benefit from intensified training in elite race walkers, The Journal of Physiology, 2016, ISSN [http://www.worldcat.org/issn/00223751 00223751], doi [http://dx.doi.org/10.1113/JP273230 10.1113/JP273230]</ref>
<ref name="ZajacPoprzecki2014">Adam Zajac, Stanisław Poprzecki, Adam Maszczyk, Miłosz Czuba, Małgorzata Michalczyk, Grzegorz Zydek, The Effects of a Ketogenic Diet on Exercise Metabolism and Physical Performance in Off-Road Cyclists, Nutrients, volume 6, issue 7, 2014, pages 2493–2508, ISSN [http://www.worldcat.org/issn/2072-6643 2072-6643], doi [http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/nu6072493 10.3390/nu6072493]</ref>
<ref name="Koeslag-1985">JH. Koeslag, LI. Levinrad, JD. Lochner, AA. Sive, Post-exercise ketosis in post-prandial exercise: effect of glucose and alanine ingestion in humans., J Physiol, volume 358, pages 395-403, Jan 1985, PMID [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3884775 3884775]</ref>
<ref name="Figlewicz-2009">DP. Figlewicz, G. Ioannou, J. Bennett Jay, S. Kittleson, C. Savard, CL. Roth, Effect of moderate intake of sweeteners on metabolic health in the rat., Physiol Behav, volume 98, issue 5, pages 618-24, Dec 2009, doi [http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2009.09.016 10.1016/j.physbeh.2009.09.016], PMID [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19815021 19815021]</ref>
<ref name="SRINIVASAN-1954">M. SRINIVASAN, IS. BHATIA, The carbohydrates of Agave vera cruz Mill. 2. Distribution in the stem and pole., Biochem J, volume 56, issue 2, pages 256-9, Feb 1954, PMID [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/13140183 13140183]</ref>
<ref name="Drake-2003">Drake, Andrew, et al. "Physiological variables related to 20 km race walk performance." ''Journal of Sports Sciences'' 21 (2003): 269-270.</ref>
<ref name="Phinney-2011-p31">Phd Stephen D. Phinney MD, Rd Jeff S. Volek Phd, [http://www.amazon.com/The-Art-Science-Carbohydrate-Living/dp/0983490708 The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Living: An Expert Guide to Making the Life-saving Benefits of Carbohydrate Restriction Sustainable and Enjoyable], 2011, publisher Beyond Obesity LLC, isbn 978-0-9834907-0-8, Page 31</ref>
</references>
[[Category:Nutrition]][[Category:Science]]
