Difference between revisions of "AltoLab"

Revision as of 16:03, 5 August 2011

AltoLab is a cheap and effective way of altitude training. It uses a chemical (soda lime) to remove the CO₂ from your exhaled breath, allowing you to rebreathe the air that now has lower O₂.

1 Introduction

The AltoLab consists of a breathing tube and lid, a cylinder of CO₂ absorbent (Hypoxic Silo) and a series of tubes filled with foam cylinders that hold your exhaled breath for you to re-breathe (mixers). Each mixer is supposed to be around 5,000 feet of altitude, though this obviously varies a lot.

AltoLab components

Below is a copy of the AltoLab manual page showing how the system works.

How AltoLab Works (click for a larger image)

2 Results

So far, I've used the AltoLab system for four bouts of training with each bout consisting of 15 daily sessions. I've found that training with AltoLab makes a difference to my performance both at altitude and at low levels. The training effect seems to build slowly, so it's not an obvious, dramatic change. However, I believe that the effect may compound over time, as the benefits of altitude training make me faster, which in turn allows for harder training as well as improved race performance.

3 Observations

• The first training bout was the hardest to keep up. Each subsequent bout seems easier, but I'm not sure why. It may be that my body is remembering the adaptation, or it may be that I just know what to expect.
• The manual suggests starting with 2 mixers, which should give a blood O₂ saturation of 90%. Mine dropped to below 80%, which may be part of the reason I do so badly at altitude. By the fifth session I found my breathing pattern changed, and my saturation did not drop as far.
• For the first few sessions of my first training bout, I ignored the manual and let my blood O₂ saturation drop to around 80%. This was enough to make me feel light headed and my vision to change. After 6-8 sessions, the saturation dropping to 80% did not cause the same problems.
• After the first training bout, I ignored the manual even further and went directly to 4 mixers, and let my O₂ saturation drop to around 75-70%.
• One simple test I did to check the effectiveness of AltoLab was to check my O₂ saturation when flying. After using the AltoLab, I found that my O₂ saturation was noticeably higher than before. (I used a barometric altimeter to check the cabin pressure to make sure the circumstances were similar.)
• After my first training bout I tended to ignore the slow, steady build up of intensity that the manual recommends and use four mixers (equiv 20,000ft) and aim to drop my O₂ saturation to around 70-75%.
• I've yet to keep the training up beyond the initial 15 day initial sessions. In theory you can 'top up' your altitude training after a 15 day break with 5 daily sessions. This is then repeated with 15 days off, 5 days on.
• It's important to let everything dry between uses, especially the bacterial filter. If it gets damp, it is hard to breathe through.
• Air you breathe through the AltoLab is quite warm, partly due to rebreathing exhaled air, partly due to the heat from the CO₂ scrubber. I tend to drink something in the rest periods.
• The downside to using the AltoLab is probably similar to other altitude training systems; being in a low O₂ environment is unpleasant. I find myself struggling to perform the training sessions as the feeling of asphyxiation was off putting.
• In theory you can watch TV while doing the AltoLab, and that’s how I used it, but the low O₂ saturation can make it hard to concentrate at times.
• If my O₂ saturation drops below about 65% I tend to phase out, and it’s easy to drop into a strange dream like state for a few moments. This is almost a shamanistic experience, but I try to avoid this situation as it's probably quite unhealthy.
• Reading a book while using the AltoLab is tricky because you need to hold the tube in your mouth.
• You need to keep the mouth piece angled upwards to prevent saliva flowing into the system. If you don't the anti-bacteria filter will be hard to breathe through and the tube will fill up!
• For the first couple of bouts of AltoLab training, the initial sessions seemed to leave me a little weakened and slower than normal. I also found that the altitude training tended to give me a headache that would come back periodically.
• I found there is quite a bit of lag in using AltoLab. When you start breathing through the AltoLab, it will take a couple of minutes before your O₂ saturation drops, and when you have the rest period, it can also take a minute or more before your O₂ saturation returns to near normal. However, I also found that the feeling of low O₂ saturation seemed to lag even further behind the reading from the meter (Pulse Oximeter). My assumption is that the O₂ saturation of your blood can change, but the tissues your blood is supplying will take time to change to match the O₂ saturation of your blood. The practical implication is that my blood O₂ saturation could drop to 65% quickly and I would feel more or less okay for a short time. Once my blood O₂ saturation had been low for a minute or so, the impact would kick in and I'd start to feel light headed. Likewise, when I had a rest period, my blood O₂ saturation would rise to normal but my head would still be feeling the effects.
• I wrote some software that would interface with a USB enabled pulse oximeter. This gave me a graph of how my blood O₂ saturation was changing over time. It also allowed me to calculate the 'Hypoxic Training Index' so I could compare different training sessions.

4 Conclusion

Overall, I think the AltoLab is a cost effective and useful way of training for high altitude conditions, and possibly for improvements at sea level. I suspect that the downsides of using other intermittent systems will be similar to AltoLab. From what I understand from other people who've slept in altitude tents, there are different, but equally significant downsides to that approach, including poor sleep quality.

5 The parts ordered

I ordered the following components

• The starter kit ($190) and which contains 3 mixers giving 5,000-15,000 ft of elevation, 2 CO₂ scrubbers proving 4 hours of usage, and the tubes.
• Three extra mixers for $36
• Six extra CO₂ scrubbers for $108 (I did not need these)
• A Finger Pulse Oximeter SM-110 which appears identical to the AltoLab Oximeter, but for $50 rather than $200.
• Bulk CO₂ scrubber. Each 3 pound bag is $7.80 + $10 shipping.
  • I ordered 'JorVet J-553 Soda Lime', produced by Jorgensen Laboratories. I got mine from shopmedvet.com, and they tend to change their URLs so you may have to search for 'soda lime' on their site. As of 6/22/11 the link http://www.shopmedvet.com/product/soda-lime-3-lb-bag/jorgensen-products-anesthesia-products worked.
• After some time, I ordered extra anti-bacterial filters, which cost less than $5 from a medical supplier. I got mine from [Allegro Medical]

Total cost was $306 (excluding the unused scrubbers). An alternative would be to buy

• The breathing kit for $89
• Three extra mixers for $36
• One or two scrubbers for $22 each
• The Pulse Oximeter for $50

With the scrubber, that works out as $214.80

6 CO₂ Scrubber

• The CO₂ scrubber lasted for two sessions of an hour, 6 minutes on, 3 minutes off. AltoLab claim 2-3 sessions.
• The scrubber did not die quickly or obviously; I just found my blood O₂ saturation not dropping as far each time. Swapping to a new scrubber returned to the original behavior.
• The absorbent material (soda lime) has a color change that indicates when it is exhausted. After the scrubber had become ineffective, the color change had not occurred. This suggests that there is more life left in the absorbent material, but there is not enough material for it to work effectively. Using two scrubbers together may get more life out of the material.
• I created a video of opening the silo for scrubber replacement at http://youtu.be/6uK1Ua8ENGU

7 Running Costs

Each CO₂ scrubber costs $22, or $18 when you by 6 at a time. This works out as a running cost of nearly $10 per hour, which can get a little pricey. I have found that the scrubbers open up quite easily, and can be refilled with a bulk CO₂ scrubber. I used JorVet soda lime (see above) which is $10 for 3 pounds. Each CO₂ scrubber holds about half a pound, and lasts for 3-4 sessions, rather than 2-3 for the original. This reduces the running cost less than $1 per hour.

8 What about just breathing through a tube?

Occasionally people ask if you can just breathe through a tube or snorkel rather than buying a system. Sadly, this does not work. All that happens is the CO2 in the tube builds up, so you breathe faster without lowering your O₂ saturation.

9 Pure DIY

Looking at the parts for the AltoLab, it seems possible to construct one out of PVC piping, some foam, CPAP tube, etc., but this may require some effort to find the right parts. Given that the AltoLab system is only the cost of a couple of pairs of good running shoes, it does not seem worth the effort.

10 See Also

• Altitude Training
• Altitude Training Approaches
• Book Review – Altitude Training and Athletic Performance
• Intermittent Hypoxic Exposure and Intermittent Hypoxic Exposure 101
• Comparison of Altitude Training Systems