Calories burned running and walking

From Fellrnr.com, Running tips
Jump to: navigation, search

Knowing how many calories you burn during exercise can be useful both for weight loss and overall health. If you're trying to lose weight, then burning more calories may help, and if you're on a calorie controlled diet, then understanding your calorie burn becomes critical for managing your calorie intake. Understanding how fast your burning calories also has an implication for overall health, as it's a useful measure of exercise intensity. If you're running, you burn the same number of calories per mile regardless of speed. That means the rate your burning calories is directly proportional to your pace. Walking is rather different, and the faster you walk, the more calories it takes to cover each mile. The calories burnt in both running and walking are also directly proportional to your body weight, so the heavier you are the more calories you burn. In addition, you obviously burn more calories it going uphill than on the level, and for modest slopes you burn less calories and going downhill. This page will allow you to estimate your calorie burn for different paces and slopes. By default, this page shows the values for a 150 pound person, but you can use the form below to customize it.

Body Weight (optional)

1 The Difference Between Running and Walking

Running and walking are two different forms of movement. In running you either have one foot on the ground or both feet in the air; both feet are never on the ground at the same time. In contrast, when walking you either have one or both feet on the ground and never have both feet in the air. Sometimes people think that basic physics means that it should take the same energy to move a human over a given distance regardless of running or walking. However, both running and walking are quite inefficient, so most of the energy expended does not go to forward movement. This is most easily seen when you compare a runner with a cyclist; for the same effort, the cyclist will move far faster. This means that the energy cost of running and walking is mostly around how much energy is wasted in each form of movement.

2 Do You Burn More Calories Running or Walking?

Generally, the answer is that running burns more calories per mile than walking, but as is so often the case, the real answer is "it depends".

  • If you're running at a moderate pace, you burn more calories per mile and per hour than walking at a moderate pace.
  • If you're race walking, then you can burn more calories per mile than running. (Race walking here is faster than about 14:00 min/mile.)
  • The relative Calories per hour for race walking and running will depend on the exact paces.

3 Should You Run or Walk in an Ultramarathon?

The table below gives some insight into when you should run and when you should walk in an ultra. This table shows how the slope would change your pace if you keep the same effort (Calories per hour). The first column is the running pace on the flat, then each column shows the pace you would travel if you run or walk on various slopes. The table is based on the available research, and there are obviously some practical limitations that make some values unreasonable for most people. As noted above, it's more efficient to walk than to run on level ground, up to the natural transition pace of about 14:00 min/mile. What's surprising is that it is also more efficient to run than walk on uphill sections, even as the equivalent pace drops. So, if you're able to run at a 10:00 min/mile on the flat, you could go up a 10% grade with the same effort at 16:35 min/mile when running or 17:39 min/mile when walking. This seems rather bizarre when both paces are below the natural transition pace (see below), but when I tested this out I found to my surprise it appears to be true. That doesn't mean you should run up the hills, as walking may be a useful break and using different muscles may help with fatigue. In addition, unless you've practiced race walking technique it's unlikely you'll be able to efficiently hit the faster downhill walking paces, where you may be able to hit the downhill running pace. For example, if you're running a 10:00 min/mile pace on the level, you may be able to handle running the 5:59 min/mile pace down a 10% decline, but few people will be able to walk at a 7:28 min/mile pace down the same slope. So it may not make much difference if you take walking breaks uphill or on the level, but you don't want to take them on the downhill sections. (In the table below, I've used a blue font where the walking pace is faster than the equivalent running pace.)

Equiv Pace on Slope
-10% -8% -6% -4% -2% 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20%
Flat Running Pace Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk Run Walk
5:00 2:59 5:40 3:16 6:02 3:37 6:25 4:01 6:50 4:29 7:16 5:00 7:43 5:34 8:12 6:11 8:43 6:51 9:15 7:33 9:48 8:17 10:23 9:04 10:60 9:53 11:38 10:44 12:17 11:36 12:58 12:31 13:40
6:00 3:35 6:07 3:56 6:32 4:21 6:60 4:50 7:29 5:23 8:00 6:00 8:33 6:41 9:08 7:25 9:46 8:13 10:25 9:03 11:07 9:57 11:50 10:53 12:36 11:52 13:23 12:52 14:13 13:56 15:05 15:01 15:58
7:00 4:11 6:31 4:35 6:60 5:04 7:31 5:38 8:05 6:17 8:41 7:00 9:20 7:48 10:02 8:39 10:46 9:35 11:33 10:34 12:23 11:36 13:16 12:42 14:12 13:50 15:10 15:01 16:11 16:15 17:15 17:31 18:22
8:00 4:47 6:52 5:14 7:24 5:47 7:60 6:26 8:38 7:11 9:20 8:00 10:05 8:54 10:53 9:53 11:45 10:57 12:40 12:04 13:39 13:16 14:42 14:31 15:49 15:49 16:59 17:10 18:13 18:34 19:31 20:01 20:53
9:00 5:23 7:11 5:54 7:47 6:31 8:26 7:15 9:09 8:04 9:56 9:00 10:47 10:01 11:43 11:08 12:42 12:19 13:47 13:35 14:56 14:55 16:10 16:19 17:28 17:47 18:52 19:19 20:21 20:53 21:55 22:31 23:34
10:00 5:59 7:28 6:33 8:08 7:14 8:51 8:03 9:39 8:58 10:31 10:00 11:29 11:08 12:31 12:22 13:39 13:41 14:53 15:06 16:13 16:35 17:39 18:08 19:11 19:46 20:50 21:27 22:36 23:13 24:29 25:01 26:28
11:00 6:34 7:44 7:12 8:27 7:58 9:14 8:51 10:07 9:52 11:05 11:00 12:09 12:15 13:19 13:36 14:36 15:03 16:00 16:36 17:32 18:14 19:12 19:57 20:59 21:44 22:56 23:36 25:01 25:32 27:16 27:31 29:42
12:00 7:10 7:59 7:51 8:45 8:41 9:36 9:39 10:33 10:46 11:37 12:00 12:48 13:22 14:06 14:50 15:33 16:25 17:08 18:07 18:53 19:54 20:48 21:46 22:54 23:43 25:11 25:45 27:40 27:51 30:23 30:01 33:21
13:00 7:46 8:13 8:31 9:02 9:25 9:57 10:28 10:59 11:40 12:08 13:00 13:26 14:28 14:53 16:04 16:30 17:48 18:18 19:37 20:18 21:33 22:30 23:35 24:57 25:42 27:38 27:54 30:37 30:10 33:56 32:31 37:41
14:00 8:22 8:26 9:10 9:18 10:08 10:17 11:16 11:24 12:33 12:39 14:00 14:04 15:35 15:40 17:19 17:29 19:10 19:30 21:08 21:46 23:13 24:19 25:24 27:10 27:40 30:23 30:02 34:00 32:30 38:13 35:02 N/A
15:00 8:58 8:38 9:49 9:33 10:51 10:36 12:04 11:48 13:27 13:09 15:00 14:42 16:42 16:28 18:33 18:28 20:32 20:45 22:38 23:20 24:52 26:17 27:12 29:39 29:39 33:31 32:11 38:07 34:49 N/A 37:32 N/A
16:00 9:34 8:50 10:28 9:48 11:35 10:54 12:52 12:11 14:21 13:39 16:00 15:20 17:49 17:16 19:47 19:30 21:54 22:04 24:09 25:01 26:32 28:27 29:01 32:28 31:37 37:19 34:20 N/A 37:08 N/A N/A N/A
17:00 10:10 9:00 11:08 10:02 12:18 11:12 13:41 12:34 15:15 14:08 17:00 15:58 18:56 18:05 21:01 20:34 23:16 23:27 25:39 26:51 28:11 30:53 30:50 35:49 33:36 N/A 36:29 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
18:00 10:46 9:11 11:47 10:15 13:02 11:29 14:29 12:56 16:09 14:37 18:00 16:36 20:02 18:55 22:15 21:40 24:38 24:56 27:10 28:52 29:50 33:43 32:39 N/A 35:35 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
19:00 11:21 9:20 12:26 10:27 13:45 11:46 15:17 13:17 17:02 15:06 19:00 17:14 21:09 19:47 23:30 22:50 26:00 26:33 28:41 31:10 31:30 37:13 34:28 N/A 37:33 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
20:00 11:57 9:30 13:06 10:39 14:29 12:02 16:06 13:39 17:56 15:34 20:00 17:53 22:16 20:40 24:44 24:05 27:22 28:20 30:11 33:52 33:09 N/A 36:16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
21:00 12:33 9:39 13:45 10:51 15:12 12:17 16:54 13:60 18:50 16:03 21:00 18:32 23:23 21:36 25:58 25:25 28:44 30:21 31:42 37:18 34:49 N/A 38:05 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
22:00 13:09 9:47 14:24 11:02 15:55 12:32 17:42 14:20 19:44 16:31 22:00 19:13 24:30 22:34 27:12 26:53 30:07 32:43 33:12 N/A 36:28 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
23:00 13:45 9:55 15:03 11:13 16:39 12:47 18:30 14:41 20:38 17:00 23:00 19:54 25:36 23:36 28:26 28:30 31:29 35:39 34:43 N/A 38:08 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
24:00 14:21 10:03 15:43 11:24 17:22 13:01 19:19 15:01 21:32 17:29 24:00 20:37 26:43 24:42 29:40 30:20 32:51 N/A 36:13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
25:00 14:57 10:10 16:22 11:34 18:06 13:16 20:07 15:21 22:25 17:58 25:00 21:21 27:50 25:53 30:55 32:31 34:13 N/A 37:44 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

4 The Effect of Incline

It's intuitively obvious that running or walking uphill is harder than level ground. It's also reasonably obvious that modest downhill slopes are easier than level ground, but as the slope increases so the difficulty becomes greater. Scientific research has supported and quantified this[1], showing that the energy cost of walking or running is to lowest at about 10% decline. There is some evidence that the slope of minimum energy is independent of pace[2]. This slope of minimum energy requirement seems to corresponds with the slope that neither requires pushing back for forward movement nor energy dissipation for braking[3]. The two graphs below show the relationship between slope and the cost of walking/running as measured by a number of studies.

The energy cost of running for various slopes.
The energy cost of walking for various slopes.

There are a number of factors that could change these assumptions:

  • A study looked at the energy cost of uphill, level, and downhill running before and after a 65Km mountainous ultramarathon[4]. After the race, the energy cost of uphill running was unchanged, but both level and downhill running were significantly harder by 8% (level) and 13% (downhill). These differences were greatest for the slowest runners and at least for the fastest runners.
  • A similar study of a rather more extreme 303 Km mountain ultramarathon found that the energy cost of uphill running and walking was lower after the race[5]. This result is a little surprising, and it's unclear why runners would do better fatigued than fresh. (The study did not look at level or downhill running.)
  • I've found no research on the effect of training on the energy cost of running uphill or downhill. I would expect that downhill training would reduce the energy cost of downhill running.

5 The Transition Between Running and Walking

The energy required to run a given distance is the roughly the same regardless of pace. This is different to walking, where the energy required to walk a given distance generally goes up with pace. This means that at slow speeds, it costs less energy to walk than run, but as you go faster it becomes easier to run. When people are put on a treadmill and the speed gradually increased, they will naturally transition from walking to running. This transition occurs at roughly the same speed for most people and is called the Preferred Transition Speed (PTS)[6]. You can see this in the two graphs below. The graph on the left shows the energy expenditure over time, showing the energy required to walk goes up faster than for running. The graph on the right shows the cost per distance, with running staying constant and the cost of walking rising with pace. (It takes more energy to walk a distance very slowly, so the graph shows the low point which is the lowest energy cost to cover a distance.)

Energy cost over time.
Energy cost over distance.

6 Calories Per Hour

This table shows the number of Calories used per hour for a person weighing 164 Pounds.

Slope Running per hour (pace in min/mile) Walk per hour (pace in min/mile)
14:00 13:00 12:00 11:00 10:00 9:00 8:00 7:00 6:00 30:00 25:00 20:00 19:00 18:00 17:00 16:00 15:00 14:00 13:00 12:00 11:00 10:00
0.0% 441 475 515 562 618 687 773 883 1,030 186 211 267 284 307 332 364 400 446 503 575 665 786
0.5% 454 489 530 578 636 707 795 909 1,060 194 223 282 300 323 349 379 416 463 522 595 687 810
1.0% 467 503 545 595 654 727 818 934 1,090 204 233 294 313 337 364 398 436 484 545 620 715 834
1.5% 480 517 560 611 672 747 840 960 1,120 214 245 309 328 350 381 413 452 501 563 640 736 864
2.0% 493 531 575 627 690 767 863 986 1,150 222 254 321 341 367 395 431 472 523 586 660 758 888
2.5% 506 545 590 644 708 787 885 1,011 1,180 232 266 336 357 380 409 446 488 540 605 685 785 918
3.0% 519 558 605 660 726 807 908 1,037 1,210 242 276 348 369 397 427 461 508 561 623 705 807 942
3.5% 531 572 620 676 744 827 930 1,063 1,240 250 288 363 385 410 441 480 524 579 646 730 835 966
4.0% 549 591 640 698 768 853 960 1,097 1,280 260 300 375 398 427 459 495 544 596 665 750 856 996
4.5% 561 605 655 715 786 873 983 1,123 1,310 270 310 390 414 440 473 514 560 617 688 770 878 1,020
5.0% 574 618 670 731 804 893 1,005 1,149 1,340 278 322 402 426 457 491 529 576 634 706 795 905 1,044
5.5% 591 637 690 753 828 920 1,035 1,183 1,380 288 331 417 442 470 505 548 596 656 725 815 927 1,074
6.0% 604 651 705 769 846 940 1,058 1,209 1,410 298 343 429 455 487 522 563 612 673 748 835 949 1,098
6.5% 621 669 725 791 870 967 1,088 1,243 1,450 306 355 444 471 500 536 581 632 690 766 860 976 1,122
7.0% 634 683 740 807 888 987 1,110 1,269 1,480 316 365 456 483 517 554 596 648 711 789 880 998 1,152
7.5% 651 702 760 829 912 1,013 1,140 1,303 1,520 326 377 471 499 530 568 611 668 729 808 905 1,025 1,176
8.0% 669 720 780 851 936 1,040 1,170 1,337 1,560 334 386 483 512 547 586 630 684 750 826 925 1,047 1,200
8.5% 686 738 800 873 960 1,067 1,200 1,371 1,600 344 398 498 527 560 600 645 700 767 849 945 1,069 1,230
9.0% 699 752 815 889 978 1,087 1,223 1,397 1,630 354 410 510 540 577 614 664 720 789 868 970 1,096 1,254
9.5% 716 771 835 911 1,002 1,113 1,253 1,431 1,670 362 420 525 556 590 632 679 736 806 891 990 1,118 1,278
10.0% 733 789 855 933 1,026 1,140 1,283 1,466 1,710 372 432 537 568 607 646 698 756 823 909 1,015 1,140 1,308
10.5% 750 808 875 955 1,050 1,167 1,313 1,500 1,750 382 442 552 584 620 664 713 772 844 928 1,035 1,167 1,332
11.0% 767 826 895 976 1,074 1,193 1,343 1,534 1,790 390 454 564 597 637 678 731 792 861 951 1,055 1,189 1,362
11.5% 784 845 915 998 1,098 1,220 1,373 1,569 1,830 400 463 579 613 650 695 746 808 883 969 1,080 1,211 1,386

7 Calories Per Distance

This table shows the number of Calories used to cover a milefor a person weighing 164 Pounds.

Slope Running Walk 30:00
min/mile
Walk 25:00
min/mile
Walk 20:00
min/mile
Walk 19:00
min/mile
Walk 18:00
min/mile
Walk 17:00
min/mile
Walk 16:00
min/mile
Walk 15:00
min/mile
Walk 14:00
min/mile
Walk 13:00
min/mile
Walk 12:00
min/mile
Walk 11:00
min/mile
Walk 10:00
min/mile
0.0% 103 93 88 89 90 92 94 97 100 104 109 115 122 131
0.5% 106 97 93 94 95 97 99 101 104 108 113 119 126 135
1.0% 109 102 97 98 99 101 103 106 109 113 118 124 131 139
1.5% 112 107 102 103 104 105 108 110 113 117 122 128 135 144
2.0% 115 111 106 107 108 110 112 115 118 122 127 132 139 148
2.5% 118 116 111 112 113 114 116 119 122 126 131 137 144 153
3.0% 121 121 115 116 117 119 121 123 127 131 135 141 148 157
3.5% 124 125 120 121 122 123 125 128 131 135 140 146 153 161
4.0% 128 130 125 125 126 128 130 132 136 139 144 150 157 166
4.5% 131 135 129 130 131 132 134 137 140 144 149 154 161 170
5.0% 134 139 134 134 135 137 139 141 144 148 153 159 166 174
5.5% 138 144 138 139 140 141 143 146 149 153 157 163 170 179
6.0% 141 149 143 143 144 146 148 150 153 157 162 167 174 183
6.5% 145 153 148 148 149 150 152 155 158 161 166 172 179 187
7.0% 148 158 152 152 153 155 157 159 162 166 171 176 183 192
7.5% 152 163 157 157 158 159 161 163 167 170 175 181 188 196
8.0% 156 167 161 161 162 164 166 168 171 175 179 185 192 200
8.5% 160 172 166 166 167 168 170 172 175 179 184 189 196 205
9.0% 163 177 171 170 171 173 174 177 180 184 188 194 201 209
9.5% 167 181 175 175 176 177 179 181 184 188 193 198 205 213
10.0% 171 186 180 179 180 182 183 186 189 192 197 203 209 218
10.5% 175 191 184 184 185 186 188 190 193 197 201 207 214 222
11.0% 179 195 189 188 189 191 192 195 198 201 206 211 218 227
11.5% 183 200 193 193 194 195 197 199 202 206 210 216 222 231

8 Training Status Effects

The graph on the below shows that there are slight, non-significant differences between runners and active non-runners. This indicates that training does not change the transition speed, though it's worth noting that the actual transition speed is slower than would be expected from the energy costs[6]. Also note that the actual cost of running is not quite constant with speed, but actually goes down as you go faster.

The energy cost for runners and non-runners, showing the Preferred Transition Speed (PTS) and the Energetically Optimal Transition Speed (ETOS).

9 Formula

for those who like to create their own tables, below are the underlying formulas that I'm using. The cost of running (Cri) and walking (Cwi) on a slope is given by these equations:

Cri = 155.4i5 - 30.4i4 - 43.3i3 + 46.3i2 + 19.5i + 3.6
Cwi = 280.5i5 - 58.7i4- 76.8i3+ 51.9i22+ 19.6i + 2.5

Where i is the slope and the result I in Jules per Kg per Meter.

10 References

  1. AE. Minetti, C. Moia, GS. Roi, D. Susta, G. Ferretti, Energy cost of walking and running at extreme uphill and downhill slopes., J Appl Physiol, volume 93, issue 3, pages 1039-46, Sep 2002, doi 10.1152/japplphysiol.01177.2001, PMID 12183501
  2. Minetti, A. E., L. P. Ardigo, and F. Saibene. "Mechanical determinants of the minimum energy cost of gradient running in humans." Journal of Experimental Biology 195.1 (1994): 211-225.
  3. K. L. Snyder, R. Kram, J. S. Gottschall, The role of elastic energy storage and recovery in downhill and uphill running, Journal of Experimental Biology, volume 215, issue 13, 2012, pages 2283–2287, ISSN 0022-0949, doi 10.1242/jeb.066332
  4. Gianluca Vernillo, Aldo Savoldelli, Andrea Zignoli, Spyros Skafidas, Alessandro Fornasiero, Antonio La Torre, Lorenzo Bortolan, Barbara Pellegrini, Federico Schena, Energy cost and kinematics of level, uphill and downhill running: fatigue-induced changes after a mountain ultramarathon, Journal of Sports Sciences, volume 33, issue 19, 2015, pages 1998–2005, ISSN 0264-0414, doi 10.1080/02640414.2015.1022870
  5. Gianluca Vernillo, Aldo Savoldelli, Spyros Skafidas, Andrea Zignoli, Antonio La Torre, Barbara Pellegrini, Guido Giardini, Pietro Trabucchi, Grégoire P. Millet, Federico Schena, An Extreme Mountain Ultra-Marathon Decreases the Cost of Uphill Walking and Running, Frontiers in Physiology, volume 7, 2016, ISSN 1664-042X, doi 10.3389/fphys.2016.00530
  6. 6.0 6.1 A. Rotstein, O. Inbar, T. Berginsky, Y. Meckel, Preferred transition speed between walking and running: effects of training status., Med Sci Sports Exerc, volume 37, issue 11, pages 1864-70, Nov 2005, PMID 16286854